Horses cause erosion on trails



Dear Editor:

Re: Is there no place that is sacred anymore? (Pioneer July 21st) Messrs. Wallin and F. Christensen have put forth the argument that alpine terrain is highly sensitive and cycling activities are more damaging to the environment than say, hiking or horseback riding.

On the contrary, there is a large body of research comparing trail user groups and their impact on the environment.

In 1994, Wilson and Seney found no statistically significant difference between measured bicycling and hiking effects. They did find that horses caused the most erosion of the trails, and they concluded, “Horses and hikers (hooves and feet) make more sediment available than wheels (motorcycles and off-road bicycles) on pre-wet trails, and that horses make more sediment available on dry plots as well.”

Weaver and Dale (1978), Quinn et al (1981), Soanne et al (1981) and Cole (1987), suggest that in many places, “Feet and hooves will trample more than bicycle tires. The instantaneous sheer forces exerted on a plant by a foot or hoof will have much more of a tearing effect than the rolling over and crushing force of a bicycle wheel.”

It would appear that mountain bikers are not the worst offenders with respect to trail degradation and erosion.

Re: Death by a thousand cuts (Pioneer July 28th). Mr. P. Christensen implies that a cyclist drives 20 hours for two hours of riding. This simply makes no sense.

Mr. Christensen cites locales where mountain bikers are “poaching trails.” Of the six areas listed, four of those are recognized by our provincial government as commercial tenures, or as designated recreation sites and designated trails. Specifically, Nipika, Mt. Swansea, Toby Benches (Kloosifier), and Toby Canyon (Johnson Trail Network). Characterizing the riding of these world class trail networks as “poaching” is baseless, false, and misleading.

Mr. Christensen opines, “It is about selling experience, room nights, meals, bikes, and accessories.” Exactly. A balanced scorecard of environmental, social AND economic aspects must be considered to sustain our community.

In conclusion, advocating for, designating, and constructing well designed trails, no matter the user group, will encourage people to stay on the trail. Designated trails provide the opportunity to educate the trail user, in turn mitigating the impact to the natural environment.

Whether they are located above treeline, in the valleys, front country or backcountry, not everyone is going to be happy about the location of trails, or the activities that take place thereon. But if we listen to the hyperbole of the vocal minority in our community, that rely on unsupported hypotheses, responsible development of designated trails will not proceed. Rather, irresponsible, unplanned, poorly designed and located trails, will propagate, because the demand for trails exists, and the users are being “shut out”.

Andrew Cradduck

Panorama

Just Posted

Latest round of Columbia River Treaty talks wrap up in Cranbrook

Federal, provincial, U.S. and Indigenous representatives recently met for eight round of discussions

First Nations given max compensation for Ottawa’s child-welfare discrimination

2016 ruling said feds didn’t give same funding for on-reserve kids as was given to off-reserve kids

Come run for Terry this Sunday

Terry Fox Run in Invermere raises funds for cancer research

Council rejects water bottling plant in current spot

Cites possibility to having facility built at another location in the village

Climate change website launched by Selkirk College and Columbia Basin Trust

The site features climate information for communities in the Columbia Basin and boundary region

VIDEO: Drone footage documents work to free salmon at Big Bar landslide

Video shows crews working to remove rocks and wood, and transporting salmon by helicopter

Rick Mercer calls out Conservative candidate in B.C. for fake meme

‘Not true. All fake. Please Stop,’ tweeted Rick Mercer in response

Bear killed in Kimberley after chasing girl, wreaking havoc on town

This particular brown-coloured bear has been the subject of many calls this summer; very food habituated, CO says

Police investigate after intoxicated teens clash with security at B.C. fair

18-year-old woman arrested and RCMP looking at possible assault in Victoria-area fall fair incident

Boy overdosed on illicit anti-anxiety drug found on Kelowna classroom floor, RCMP say

Noah Mills, 8, ingested a pink powdery substance off his Kelowna classroom floor

BC SPCA investigating after three dogs found shot dead in Prince George ditch

The three adult dogs appeared to be well cared for before being found with gunshot wounds, BC SPCA says

Psychiatric assessment ordered for man accused in Salmon Arm church shooting

Lawyer tells court accused was diagnosed with psychosis hours after his arrest

Surrey mom allegedly paid $400,000 for son in U.S. college bribery scam

Xiaoning Sui, 48, was arrested in Spain on Monday night

Winnipeg student, killed in bus crash, remembered as passionate, kind

University of Victoria student Emma Machado, 18, was killed in the bus crash near Bamfield on Friday

Most Read